Handout 2 - Final Project: Critical Review

Topic Proposal:  See ENG 104 Course Plan Week #10 for deadline & copy for Cora requirement.
Directions: In one or two paragraphs,
  • Describe your topic as completely and clearly as possible (e.g. identify author/s, title of work/s of narrative fiction, film adaptations, genre/s of narrative fiction, literary period or movement, critical approaches, research question or issue relevant to narrative fiction, etc.--review Topic Possibilities);
  • Explain why you have chosen this topic and/or how you became interested in investigating sources on this topic further through this short research project;
  • Be sure to state explicitly how your chosen topic is relevant to ENG 104 study of narrative fiction, and/or identify one or more ENG 104 Objectives or Learning Outcomes that a Critical Review project on this topic will enable you to broaden or deepen;
  • Address to Cora any questions or concerns you may have about your topic choice.  NOTE WELL:  Cora will offer her critique of Topic Proposals only if a copy is submitted to her on time.
Working Bibliography:  See ENG 104 Course Plan Week #10 for deadline & copy for Cora requirement.  Directions:  For each of the five (5) useful "outside" sources you've located on your topic and that you plan to include and "annotate" in your Critical Review:
  • Identify by type of source;
  • Give complete bibliographical information, following MLA documentation style examples (below) for the type of source as correctly and closely as possible;
  • Be sure you've followed assignment directions and limitations in selecting your five sources [review "Selecting Five (5) Useful 'Outside' Sources Relevant to Your Topic"]
  • Address to Cora any questions or concerns you have about identifying types of sources, following correct MLA format, and/or meeting assignment directions and limitations in selecting your five sources.  NOTE WELL:  Cora will offer her critique of Working Bibliographies only if a copy is submitted to her on time.

MLA Documentation Style - Examples

PRINT SOURCES

BOOK
Sammons, Martha C.  "A Better Country": The Worlds of Religious Fantasy and Science Fiction.  New York:
        Greenwood Press, 1988.

BOOK with an AUTHOR and an EDITOR
Plath, Sylvia. The Unabridged Journals of Sylvia Plath. Ed. Karen V. Kukil.  New York: Anchor-Doubleday,
       2000.

ARTICLE OR CHAPTER FROM A BOOK by the same author
Charters, Ann.  "Appendix 2: A Brief History of the Short Story."  The Story and Its Writer: An Introduction to
        Short Fiction.  Compact 6th ed.  Boston: Bedford/St. Martin's, 2003.  995-1002.

ARTICLE OR CHAPTER FROM A BOOK by a different author
O'Connor, Flannery.  "Writing Short Stories."  
[First published 1961.]  Rpt. The Story and Its Writer: An
        Introduction to Short Fiction.  Ed. Ann Charters.  Compact 6th ed.  Boston: Bedford-St. Martin's, 2003.
        910-915.

JOURNAL ARTICLE
Wood, Michael. "Broken Dates: Fiction and the Century." Kenyon Review 22.3 (2000): 50-64.

MAGAZINE ARTICLE
Miller, John J. “The Truth Beyond Memory. (J.R.R Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings).”  National Review
      31 December 2001: 43.

NEWSPAPER ARTICLE
Dudek, Duane. “Epic Fantasy Echoes Today’s Clash between Good and Evil.” Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
        17 December 2001, morning ed.: D2
.

REFERENCE WORKS: ARTICLE from WELL KNOWN ENCYCLOPEDIA:
Posner, Rebecca. "Romance Languages." The New Encyclopaedia Britannica: Macropaedia. 15th ed. 1987.
REFERENCE WORKS: ARTICLE from SPECIALIZED DICTIONARY:
George, Michael W. “J. R. R. Tolkien: January 3, 1892 – September 2, 1973.”  Dictionary of Literary Biography,
        Volume 255: British Fantasy and Science-Fiction Writers, 1918-1960
.  A Bruccoli Clark Layman Book.
        Ed. Darren Harris Fain.  Detroit: Gale, 2002.  237-250.

Articles from Online Subscription Database
NOT freely available on the WWW

College and university libraries must subscribe to electronic databases such as EBSCO and Lexis-Nexis--that is, an academic library must buy subscriptions (that typically cost a lot of money!) so that its academic users (e.g. COCC students and staff) can access such electronic databases.  Subscription-based electronic databases are not freely available to non-subscribers (vs. World Wide Web sites that are freely available to anyone who has an internet browser), so even if you were to try to transcribe the usually very lengthy URL of an EBSCO or Lexis Nexis article that you are citing, general non-authorized users would not be able to access it.

NEWSPAPER ARTICLE with TWO AUTHORS from EBSCO Academic Search Premier database:

Byfield, Ted, and Virginia Byfield.  "What Tolkien's Enduring Fables Can Teach Those Aiming to Captivate
       Today's Youth."  Report / Newsmagazine (National ed.) 2 Sept. 2002: 49 (1pp).
Academic Search
       Premier [
Article No. 7273966]. EBSCO. Central Oregon Community Coll. Lib., Bend, OR. 16 Oct. 2003.

WEEKLY NEWS MAGAZINE ARTICLE from Lexis-Nexis Academic Universe database:
Koretz, Gene. "Economic Trends: Uh-Oh, Warm Water." Business Week 21 July 1997: 22.  
        Academic Universe: Medical. Lexis-Nexis. Central Oregon Community Coll. Lib., Bend, OR.
       16 Nov. 2003.

ARTICLE FROM REFERENCE WORK from GALE LITERATURE CENTER database -
NOTE: 
UNSIGNED (i.e. NO AUTHOR GIVEN) - START WITH ARTICLE TITLE:
"J(ohn) R(onald) R(euel) Tolkien, 1892-1973."  [New Entry: 4 Jan. 2002.]   Contemporary Authors Online.
        The Gale Group, 2000.  Gale Literature Resource Center.  Central Oregon Community Coll. Lib., Bend,
        OR. 16 Nov. 2003.

NOTE: When you access a work through a personal subscription service such as America Online, give the information about the source, followed by the name of the service, the date of access, and the keyword used to retrieve the source.

Conniff, Richard. "The House That John Built." Smithsonian Feb. 2001.  America Online. 11 Mar. 2001.

        Keyword: Smithsonian Magazine.

SOURCES freely available on the WORLD WIDE WEB

Short Work or single Web Page from a Web site: "Short" works are those that appear in quotation marks in MLA style: articles, poems, and other documents that are not book length. For a short work from a Web site, include as many of the following elements as apply and as are available:
  • Author's name
  • Title of the short work--i.e. title of the individual web page--in quotation marks
  • Date of the short work if given on the individual web page
  • Title of the site, underlined (or italicized)
  • Date of publication or last update of the web site.
  • Sponsor of the site (if not named as the author or in the title of the web site)
  • Date you accessed the source
  • The URL in angle brackets

Usually at least some of these elements will not apply or will not be unavailable. For example, in the following models, NO AUTHOR was identified.

"The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings." [Film.] 2003.  Internet Movie Database: IMDb.com. 
        Nov. 17, 2003 <
http://us.imdb.com/Title?0120737>.

"Myth and Storytelling."  National Geographic's Beyond the Movie: The Lord of the Rings.  1996-2003.
         National Geographic.com. 17 Nov. 2003
         <
http://www.nationalgeographic.com/ngbeyond/rings/myth.html>.

BOOK REVIEW from ONLINE NEWS MAGAZINE FREELY ACCESSIBLE TO ALL:

Eaton, Anne T.  "A Delightfully Imaginative Journey."  Rev. of The Hobbit: Or, There and Back Again,
       by J. R. R. Tolkien.  New York Times Book Review, 13 March 1938.  The Tolkien Archives, New York
       Times Online. 2002. Oct. 26 2002 <
http://www.nytimes.com/1938/03/13/books/tolkien-hobbit.html>.
 

An entire Web site: Begin with the name of the author or corporate author (if known) and the title of the site, underlined (or italicized). Then give the names of any editors, the date of publication or last update, the name of any sponsoring organization, the date of access, and the URL in angle brackets. Provide as much of this information as is available.

National Geographic. National Geographic's Beyond the Movie: The Lord of the Rings.  1996-2003.
       National Geographic.com.  17 Nov. 2003 <http://www.nationalgeographic.com/ngbeyond/rings/
>.

Exploring Ancient World Cultures
. Ed. Anthony F. Beavers. 1997. Univ. of Evansville. 23 Oct. 2003
     <http://eawc.evansville.edu/index.htm>.

MLA: Modern Language Association, 2003
Home page:  http://www.mla.org
Frequently Asked Questions about MLA Style (2003)
URL: http://www.mla.org/style_faq

  • The latest edition of the MLA Handbook for Writers of Research Papers is the 6th ed., 2003

How do I document sources from the Web in my Works Cited list?
URL: http://www.mla.org/publications/style/style_faq/style_faq4

Another useful online source for MLA style is:
Hacker & Fister's Research & Documentation Online (Bedford-St. Martin's):
URL: http://www.dianahacker.com/resdoc/
Humanities: Documenting Sources: MLA Style
URL: http://www.dianahacker.com/resdoc/humanities/english.html
MLA List of Works Cited
URL: http://www.dianahacker.com/resdoc/humanities/list.html

  • Note, however, Hacker & Fister pages are based on 5th ed. of MLA Handbook for Writers of Research Papers, 1999.

ENG 104 Objectives and Learning Outcomes; or what will you learn in ENG 104? 

ENG 104 instruction, activities, and assignments are designed to help students develop skills essential to successful college-level Humanities study of literature:
(a) close reading of literary texts and annotating (taking notes on) significant passages in those texts;
(b) describing and analyzing personal responses to literary texts;
(c) applying literary terms and concepts, approaches and methods of analysis, and relevant background information introduced in class and assignments;
(d) identifying and investigating informational resources valuable to the study of narrative fiction;
(e) formulating and explaining interpretations and evaluations of literary works--drawing upon cogent logical reasoning and relevant specific examples from the works, as well as other sources;
(f) actively participating in class discussions and small-group seminars--prepared to explain and illustrate one's own interpretations and questions, as well as to understand and respond to others'  interpretations;
(g) seriously considering, and evaluating the merits and limitations of, others' opinions and evidence--especially those different from one's own; and being willing to re-think one's own interpretations and evaluations of literary works as warranted;
(h) adapting general academic writing skills to the special forms and requirements of writing successful literary criticism (i.e. literary analysis, interpretation, evaluation)

ENG 104 Learning Outcomes:  Successful completion of ENG 104 means students will be able to:

1.  Define and illustrate principal literary elements of narrative fiction (e.g. plot, character, theme, point of view, setting, symbol, style), as well as significant variations within this genre (e.g. static vs. dynamic character, short story vs. novel), using well-selected examples from representative works.

2.  Analyze relationships among selected elements of literary form and thematic content (e.g. setting and characterization, or symbol and theme) within a work of narrative fiction, to explain how these literary elements interact to shape the meaning and impact of individual works of narrative fiction.

3.  Identify key characteristics of literary historical periods and movements (e.g. 19th-century literary Realism) influential in the development of narrative fiction; and illustrate these characteristics using representative literary works.

4.  Apply background information by and about authors--e.g. their lives, cultural identities, socio-economic circumstances, reputations, literary influences, creative practices--to analysis and interpretation of their works of narrative fiction.

5.  Analyze others' literary criticism (e.g. commentaries of professional literary critics, interpretations of other ENG 104 students), and apply relevant critical opinions to one's own analysis and interpretation of narrative fiction.

6.  Use comparison/contrast analysis to demonstrate significant differences and similarities between selected works of narrative fiction (e.g., in fiction by the same or different authors; in fiction from different literary-historical periods; in different types of narrative fiction, such as short story, novel and/or film adaptation).

7.  Evaluate selected works of narrative fiction, based on defensible evaluation criteria appropriate to literary genre and context, and persuasive with a diverse English 104 audience.

8.  Demonstrate effective writing skills when communicating and supporting literary analysis, interpretation, and evaluation, in graded writing assignments.

9.  Select and interpret persuasive specific examples from primary works of narrative fiction, as well as from relevant secondary sources, in order to illustrate and support one's points.

10.  Avoid plagiarism by using an acceptable academic style (e.g. MLA) to cite direct quotations, paraphrases (indirect quotations), and summaries taken from primary and secondary sources.

See also Final Project: Critical Review Directions (Handout 1)
Go to Handout 3 - Final Project: Critical Review
(Writing the Critical Review: Manuscript Form, Introduction, 5 Sample Annotated Sources)
ENG 104 Syllabus | Course Plan | Home

Top of this page

You are here: HANDOUT 2 - Final Project: Critical Review
URL of this webpage: http://web.cocc.edu/cagatucci/classes/eng104/handout2.htm
Last Updated: 19 November 2003

Copyright © 1997-2003, Cora Agatucci, Professor of English
Humanities Department, Central Oregon Community College
Please address comments on web contents & links to Cora Agatucci
For technical problems with this web, contact COCC webhelp